|Jun 11, 13.
I have no right to have an opinion on this icon design other than using every day.
I am not attempting to look at anything else other than the designs they’ve started with.
Key “takeaway” –
Messages – the iOS one looks really bloated. Keeping the green is cool, as iOS made the world realise: Green = messaging. Completely copied in Android, everything else.
Calendar: makes me not want to use it, looks bleak and unhelpful. A calendar isn’t an icon it’s a Calendar. If you’re comparing to Android: Calendar doesn’t really have an icon, it’s a widget on one of your home-screen that actually shows….your calendar! Which is much more useful e.g.
Photos – it’s an improvement on the sunflower but looks like an oil company logo
Camera – when will this stop being a photo of a camera? My 8 yr-old niece has never seen a camera-camera. I think you do other things with the camera.
Weather – is lovely
Clock – i can’t really see it very well. My big gripe with Clock is that it’s not Clock, and that Clock has relatively teeny-weeny use-case for those that need to know the time in different area codes (area codes). What you actually want is ALARM CLOCK, for which i imagine 80% of iPhone (and 40% of iPads) are used for. Why hide it behind clock, it’s not a COCK it’s an ALARM CLOCK.
Maps – bowed to pressure and made sure the route isn’t into a river.
Videos – looks really bloated like Messages. I also don’t understand why there is a standalone video player and it’s not just in iTunes, especially on iOS you can only watch videos you’ve bought from the erroneously named iTunes
Notes – doesn’t make me want to take Notes
Reminders – looks like that new Dots game
Stocks – an improvement on previous stocks, but still: i’d rather just have a widget that showed my stocks on it, maybe with a RED button that sells SELL and a green one that says BUY #business
Game Center – a network agency –type “new logo”: the bubbles represents engagements with the customers; the white-space is…the customer. Reminds me of the Barclaycard logo re-brand.
Newsstand – a selection of New Yorker covers
iTunes Store –
App Store: pencil, paint and ruler.
Passbook – is brilliant icon, really lovely
Settings – much prefer android cos it shows settings that you can tweak. This is fine though, i suppose, are those gears?
Phone – fine, well done for making the world think green = phone, that’s quite powerful!
Mail – the least of iOS’ Mail problems are the icon. How about having to choose to search for From, To, or “All”?
Safari – this looks like Compass. Have you ever thought how little it has to do with the internet? You have to think: the internet is like exploring -> another word for exploring is a safari -> back in the 1920s you needed a compass to go on safari
Music – fine
Alex at work made a lovely point: it’s very colourful and makes most sense when you think that their big growth markets will be in China, cos i think the Chinese market will snap up how colourful this is.
What do you think?